James F. Sutton Agency

The James F. Sutton Agency is an independent insurance agency on East Main Street in East Islip, run by the same family for three generations and serving Long Island since 1963. Because it represents multiple top-rated carriers rather than a single insurer, the agency can compare options and match coverage to each client. For businesses, it writes general liability, workers’ compensation, commercial property, commercial auto, cyber liability, professional liability, business interruption, directors and officers (D&O), and employment practices liability (EPLI) policies, along with group benefits. The agency also has experience with contractors in the trades and with condominium associations. On the personal side, it offers home, auto, umbrella, boat, and life insurance, which makes it a practical option for owners who want business and personal coverage handled in one place. It serves the downstate region from New York City to Montauk.